Final Evaluation Finds Cook County Youth in Deferred Prosecution Program Less Likely to Face New Charges

The Juvenile Justice Collaborative (JJC) Care Coordination Program connects Cook County youth facing first-time felony and serious misdemeanor charges to community-based services as an alternative to prosecution. Charges are dismissed when youth complete the program. This final evaluation finds that participants were more likely to avoid prosecution and less likely to pick up new charges than similar peers, which is consistent with earlier findings.

What We Did

Chapin Hall evaluated the program’s implementation, outcomes, and impact for youth referred from July 2023 through June 2025. The Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office refers eligible youth to the JJC, a network of community providers stewarded by Strengthening Chicago’s Youth at Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago. During the evaluation, Treatment Alternatives for Safe Communities managed intake and care coordination.

Researchers analyzed program and court records. To measure impact, they compared 111 youth referred from July 2023 to June 2024 with 111 matched peers who were not referred but had the same charges and gender, similar ages, and similar neighborhoods of residence. Interviews with 7 youth and focus groups with 15 staff and stakeholders added context. All 7 youth had completed the program, so their views may not reflect the views of those who left early.

What We Found

  • Nearly all youth engaged. Of 314 referrals across both years, 96% led to an intake. More than 90% of youth referred to a community provider were connected to services. In all, 70% of youth with closed cases completed the program.
  • Participants were less likely to be prosecuted. Among youth referred from July 2023 to June 2024, 81% had their charges dropped, compared with 33% of matched peers.
  • Participants were less likely to pick up new charges. Controlling for other factors, participants had one-third of the risk of picking up a new charge compared to matched peers.
  • Relationships drove engagement. Youth valued staff who treated them with respect and adapted to their schedules. Family, especially mothers, motivated them most.
  • Some conditions made participation harder. Stakeholders pointed to housing instability, family disengagement, safety concerns when traveling to services, and waits for services to begin. Partners shortened waits and adapted communication practices as challenges arose.

What It Means

  • Secure stable funding. Move beyond time-limited grants to protect the program’s results.
  • Invest in frontline staff. Relationships with care coordinators and mentors are central to the model.
  • Treat family engagement as core work. Consistent family supports could help more youth complete the program.
  • Keep partners aligned. Shared protocols and standing meetings can prevent gaps during staff turnover.

Chapin Hall has partnered with Cook County stakeholders since the program’s 2020 pilot, building evidence and supporting quality improvement across the pilot and expansion evaluations. This final evaluation suggests that with steady support, youth facing serious charges can avoid deeper involvement with the juvenile justice system.

Contact

For more information about this report, please contact Kya Barounis.

Read the report

Read the brief

Recommended Citation
Barounis, K., Gaul-Stout, J., & Cusick, G, (2026). Final evaluation of the Juvenile Justice Collaborative's Care Coordination Program for Deferred Prosecution. Chapin Hall.