Chapin Hall Evaluation Finds Youth in Cook County Deferred Prosecution Program Had 54% Lower Odds of a New Charge
Participants were also far more likely to have charges dropped: 81% compared with 33% of similar youth who received standard case processing
Since 2020, the Juvenile Justice Collaborative (JJC) has offered deferred prosecution paired with care coordination as an alternative to traditional case processing for youth in Cook County. Chapin Hall’s final evaluation of the program’s most recent cohorts finds that youth offered the program were more likely to avoid prosecution and less likely to reoffend than a matched group of peers who were not.
Of 314 referrals to the program between July 2023 and June 2025, 96% completed an intake, and approximately 70% went on to complete the program successfully. Most referrals came from Chicago’s West and South Sides. Referred youth were predominantly male (87%) and identified as Black (65%) or Latinx (29%), reflecting the demographics of who is arrested and charged rather than a feature of the program’s design, a dynamic stakeholders described as one the program inherits rather than creates.
“Young people who are charged with a crime deserve a response that holds them accountable and gives them a real path forward. This evaluation shows that deferred prosecution paired with care coordination can do both,” said Chapin Hall Executive Director Bryan Samuels. “Because the youth referred to this program are overwhelmingly Black and Latinx young people from Chicago’s West and South Sides, getting this right is also a matter of racial equity.”
The JJC program, stewarded by Strengthening Chicago’s Youth at Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago in partnership with eleven community service providers and advisors, the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office (CCSAO) and the Circuit Court of Cook County, connects youth charged with a nonviolent felony or serious misdemeanor to care coordination and services in lieu of prosecution. To assess the program’s effect on legal outcomes, Chapin Hall compared a cohort of JJC participants to a matched comparison group of youth from the same neighborhoods, facing the same charges, during the same time period, who received standard case processing. Nearly 81% of program participants had their charges dropped, compared to 33% of youth in the comparison group; only 17% of participants were ultimately prosecuted and found guilty, compared to 58% of the comparison group. A multivariate analysis found that program participation was associated with 54% lower odds of picking up a new charge within 12 months, roughly one-third the risk faced by the comparison group. This finding replicates an earlier analysis of the program’s first ARPA-funded cohort, which found 44% lower odds of a new charge among participants.
“Experiencing the criminal legal system as a child can often be a traumatic experience leading to continued contact with the system that puts both the child and community at risk,” said Avik Das, executive director of the Cook County Justice Advisory Council. “Deferred prosecution programs that engage children early in the process with meaningful supportive services can help change their trajectory and contribute positively to their community. Successful childhoods lead to successful neighborhoods, and that includes investing in the success of children and young people involved with our court system.”
Interviews with youth participants and focus groups with care coordinators and stakeholders pointed to a consistent explanation for these results: sustained, nonjudgmental relationships between youth and program staff. “Through the entire process I was always treated like a person and not a criminal,” one youth said.
“We are encouraged to see lower rates of recidivism among youth who participated in this program and the positive impact it has made in our criminal justice system,” said Cook County State’s Attorney Eileen Burke. “Our communities are safer and stronger when young people receive the structure, individualized care, and support they need to get back on track.”
The evaluation also identified structural risks to the program’s continued effectiveness, including its dependence on time-limited grant funding, staffing instability at partner agencies, inconsistent communication of case updates to the court, and the absence of a formal continuity-of-care plan once youth are discharged after 90 days.
Based on these findings, Chapin Hall researchers recommended that Cook County pursue stable, institutionalized funding for the program and, under the leadership of Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle, the Cook County Justice Advisory Council and court system stakeholders are engaged in planning to sustain the JJC deferred prosecution program and continue to fund it via the Cook County budget. Chapin Hall researchers also recommended investing in staff development and retention; standardizing protocols and establishing formal change management processes across program partners; and revising the program’s assessment tools to better fit a youth population.
“This report shows strong and consistent results that when young people are given the time and opportunity to work with a caring adult, identify their goals, and connect to needed resources in their communities, they can thrive and move forward,” said Leslie Helmcamp, director of violence prevention initiatives and executive director of Strengthening Chicago’s Youth at Lurie Children’s. “The findings also demonstrate the value of continuous quality improvement and the meaningful outcomes that can be achieved when systems and community partners work together to create coordinated support for young people and their families.”
Chapin Hall Researcher Dr. Jennifer Gaul-Stout and Chapin Hall Senior Researcher Dr. Kya Barounis led the evaluation. Chapin Hall is an independent, mission-driven policy research center dedicated to improving the well-being of children, youth, and families. Strengthening Chicago’s Youth (SCY) is a violence prevention initiative and collaborative network convened by the Patrick M. Magoon Institute for Healthy Communities at Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago.